Call (516) 234-0789
Amazon Utility Patent Complaint and APEX Attorney
Yomtobian Law defends Amazon sellers against utility patent complaints and in Amazon Patent Evaluation Express (APEX). We chart the asserted claims against your product element by element, send Amazon a noninfringement opinion it can act on, and negotiate with the patent owner while Amazon reviews. Alan Yomtobian is a USPTO registered patent attorney with federal patent litigation experience.

What clients say
★★★★★
Alan Yomtobian was a pleasure to work with. He is knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely cares about his clients. He took the time to understand my situation, explained my options clearly, and guided me through the process with confidence and professionalism.
What stood out most was his attention to detail and willingness to answer questions promptly. I always felt informed and supported throughout the matter.
I highly recommend Alan to anyone looking for an experienced attorney who is dedicated to achieving the best possible outcome for his clients.
mustafa ada
★★★★★
Incredible service! Alan is highly responsive, deeply knowledgeable about patent law, and gets things done quickly. 5 stars all the way!
Doğukan Çelen
★★★★★
Alan provided exceptional legal support for my Amazon patent infringement case. He delivered a detailed analysis and a strong Opinion Letter very quickly. His communication was clear, professional, and reassuring throughout the process. Highly recommended for Amazon sellers dealing with IP issues!
Kruska
Two ways a utility patent complaint reaches you
-
A standard patent complaint. The rights owner reports your ASINs and Amazon removes them. Amazon's policy asks you to reply with specific reasons a mistake was made, or to provide a court order.
-
An APEX invitation. The patent owner asks Amazon for a neutral evaluation. You choose whether to take part, resolve the dispute directly, or go to court. If you do nothing, the listings come down.
The only question that matters: every element of a claim
A product infringes a utility patent claim only if it has every element of that claim. One missing element ends that claim. So the work is a claim chart: each element of each asserted claim in one column, your product in the other, with photographs and, where it helps, the product taken apart.
When Amazon's support team tells a seller what it wants in a patent appeal, it asks for an opinion that references the patent and addresses the individual claims as they relate to the product. That is exactly what we prepare.
Should you take part in APEX?
In APEX a neutral patent attorney chosen by Amazon decides, on written submissions, whether your product likely infringes one claim of the patent. Each side deposits $4,000 with the evaluator, and the side that prevails receives its deposit back. Before you pay, we read the asserted claim against your product and tell you plainly whether the noninfringement position is strong, weak, or better made in a negotiation or a courtroom.
The Federal Circuit has held that a patent owner who files an APEX complaint can be sued for a declaratory judgment in the seller's home state. SnapRays v. Lighting Defense Group, 100 F.4th 1371 (Fed. Cir. 2024). That gives sellers a third option and real leverage.

Check who owns the patent
The name on an Amazon complaint is not always the owner of the patent. USPTO assignment records are public. If the complaining party does not own the patent and is not the owner's authorized agent, that is an independent reason the complaint should not stand, and we raise it.
What to send us
-
The notice or APEX invitation, with complaint IDs and the patent number
-
Every affected ASIN
-
Product photographs, drawings or specifications, and a sample if we ask
-
Your supplier's name and when you first sold the product
-
Anything already sent to Amazon or the patent owner

Frequently asked questions
Should I pay the $4,000 APEX deposit?
Only after someone has read the asserted claim against your product. If an element of the claim is plainly missing from your product, APEX can be a fast and inexpensive win. If the question is close, a negotiated resolution or a court action may protect you better.
What happens if I ignore an APEX notice?
Amazon removes the accused listings. Ignoring the notice is a decision to lose.
Can I argue the patent is invalid?
Amazon does not generally decide validity. Its policy accepts a court order finding a patent invalid or unenforceable. Invalidity arguments still matter in negotiation and in federal court.
How long does an Amazon patent appeal take?
It depends on the number of claims and products and on Amazon's review. We begin the claim chart the day we receive the notice and product information.
Does changing my supplier or tweaking the product fix it?
Not by itself. A changed product still infringes if it has every element of a claim. We review any redesign against the claims before you manufacture it.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.