Call (516) 234-0789
Amazon Design Patent Complaint Lawyer
Yomtobian Law gets Amazon listings reinstated after design patent complaints. We compare your product to the patent drawings under the ordinary observer test, send Amazon a noninfringement submission built on that comparison, and negotiate a retraction with the rights owner in parallel. Alan Yomtobian is a USPTO registered patent attorney, Reg. No. 81,255.

What Our Clients Say
Mustafa Ada
“Alan Yomtobian was a pleasure to work with. He is knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely cares about his clients. He took the time to understand my situation, explained my options clearly, and guided me through the process with confidence and professionalism.
What stood out most was his attention to detail and willingness to answer questions promptly. I always felt informed and supported throughout the matter.
I highly recommend Alan to anyone looking for an experienced attorney who is dedicated to achieving the best possible outcome for his clients."
★★★★★
Doğukan Çelen
"Incredible service! Alan is highly responsive, deeply knowledgeable about patent law, and gets things done quickly. 5 stars all the way!"
★★★★★
Kruska
"Alan provided exceptional legal support for my Amazon patent infringement case. He delivered a detailed analysis and a strong Opinion Letter very quickly. His communication was clear, professional, and reassuring throughout the process. Highly recommended for Amazon sellers dealing with IP issues!"
★★★★★
What a design patent complaint means on Amazon
A design patent protects the way a product looks, not how it works. Its number begins with the letter D. When a rights owner reports your ASIN under a design patent, Amazon generally removes the listing and logs an intellectual property complaint on your Account Health page without deciding whether you infringe.
How a listing comes back
Amazon's policy asks a seller to reply to a patent notice with specific reasons a mistake was made, or to provide a court order. In practice there are two working routes, and we run both at once.
-
A noninfringement submission. A side by side showing that an ordinary observer would not take your product for the patented design.
-
A retraction. The rights owner withdraws the complaint, usually after seeing the same comparison and a clear statement of what happens if they do not.
Amazon's neutral evaluation program, APEX, is for utility patents. If your notice mentions an evaluation, send it to us before you respond.
Why "my product came first" rarely works
Sellers often answer that their product was on sale before the patent was filed. That is an argument that the patent is invalid, and Amazon does not rule on validity outside a court order. It can matter a great deal in negotiation with the rights owner and in federal court. It rarely moves Amazon on its own.

The three way comparison
Design patent infringement asks whether an ordinary observer, familiar with the prior art, would think the accused product is the same design as the patent. The leading case is Egyptian Goddess, Inc. v. Swisa, Inc., 543 F.3d 665 (Fed. Cir. 2008) (en banc). We build the comparison in three columns:
-
The claimed design. The patent figures. Solid lines are claimed. Broken lines show environment and are not part of the claim.
-
Your product. Photographed from the same angle as each figure.
-
The closest prior art. Earlier designs that show how crowded the field is, which narrows what the patent can cover.
If your product sits closer to the prior art than to the patent, that is the submission. If it sits closer to the patent, we tell you so and talk about redesign and resolution instead.
What to send us
-
The notice, with the complaint ID and patent number
-
Photographs of your product from the front, back, both sides, top and bottom
-
The date you first sold the product and where
-
Anything already sent to Amazon or to the rights owner

What to avoid in the first 48 hours
Do not relist under a new ASIN. Do not delete the listing. Do not send the rights owner an angry email. Do not submit a generic plan of action. Each one makes a winnable complaint harder. Contact us so we can prepare a plan to get your product back on Amazon fast!
Frequently asked questions
Can I get a design patent complaint removed from my Amazon account?
Yes, in many cases. The complaint comes off when the rights owner retracts it or when Amazon accepts that the complaint was a mistake. A noninfringement comparison prepared by patent counsel supports both.
Will Amazon accept a letter from my attorney?
Amazon reviews submissions that give specific reasons a mistake was made. A short letter that only states a conclusion is often rejected. A submission that walks through the patent figures against your product, view by view, gives the reviewer something to act on.
How long does reinstatement take?
It depends on Amazon's review queue and on how quickly the rights owner engages. We send the first submission as soon as the comparison is complete and open talks with the rights owner the same day.
What if the rights owner will not respond?
We escalate inside Amazon and advise on a declaratory judgment action in federal court, which can produce the court order Amazon's policy names.
Do I need a patent attorney, or can a reinstatement service handle it?
A design patent complaint turns on a legal comparison of your product to the patent. A registered patent attorney is trained and licensed to make that comparison and to negotiate with the rights owner's counsel.